Loki: Dorian Gray in The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen.
Steve: Johnny Storm from the Fantastic Four.
Tony: Kid Flash. No, Wiccan. Actually no, Batman. Maybe Robin, but only in Teen Titans and Young Justice. I’m going to stick with Batman I think. Then again, Kid Flash has powers…
Natasha: Castiel in Supernatural.
Clint: Katniss.
Natasha: Katniss isn’t a superhero.
Clint: And Castiel is?
Natasha: At least he has powers.
Clint: You don’t have powers, and you’re still a superhero. People don’t have to have superpowers to be superheroes. Batman, Iron Man, Robin…
Natasha: Katniss still doesn’t count.
Clint: Fine, Jean Grey, because she’s hot. And you?
Natasha: Nightcrawler, for the same reason.
Clint: Gambit is way better than Nightcrawler.
Natasha: I guess that says something about my taste in men.
Bruce: Can I say Soren from Legend of the Guardians: The Owls of Ga’hoole? I have a feeling that if Katniss doesn’t count, he definitely will not.
Steve: If Soren is allowed, I want to change my answer to Hiccup in How to Train your Dragon.
Tony: Well if everyone’s changing their answers to stupid ones, I’ll say Sherlock Holmes.
Thor: Superman.
Loki: Discounting Aquaman, Superman is the worst superhero.
Thor: How so?
Loki: There was no thought put into him as a character; they just decided to make an infinitely powerful alien, and then to avoid it being completely ridiculous they made a glowing green rock that could render him powerless. It’s hardly the work of a brilliant character creator.
Thor: You are just jealous of his powers, brother. Superman is the ultimate hero.
Phil: Wait does that mean I can choose Captain now?